Criminal cases in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) follow a specific set of rules and procedures, as outlined in the Federal Law No. 35 of 1992, amended to ensure a fair and efficient judicial process. This legal framework provides guidelines for conducting criminal investigations, trials, rendering judgments, and appealing the decisions at higher courts, as well as implementing penalties.

brown wooden gavel on brown wooden table
Photo by EKATERINA BOLOVTSOVA on Pexels.com

To commence a criminal case in the UAE, the victim must first file a complaint against the offender with the police, detailing the incident and sequence of events related to the crime. Following that, the police will initiate an investigation aimed at gathering evidence, interrogating suspects, and collecting testimonies from witnesses. The findings will then be presented to the public prosecutor, who will decide whether to pursue a case in court.

Transparency and adherence to justice remain at the forefront of the UAE’s legal system, with notable efforts to uphold these principles in various proceedings taking place in the country’s courts. As criminal cases continue to evolve, it is essential that the UAE’s legal system adapts to address emerging challenges and maintains its commitment to fair and equal treatment of all parties involved.

Understanding Criminal Cases in UAE

Classification of Crimes

In the UAE, criminal cases are primarily divided into two categories: felonies and misdemeanours. Felonies are considered more serious crimes and carry heavier penalties, such as imprisonment for more than a year or even the death penalty. Misdemeanours, on the other hand, are minor offenses and are punishable by fines or imprisonment for less than a year in local prisons.

Federal Law No. 35 of 1992

The procedures for criminal cases in the UAE are defined by the Federal Law No. 35 of 1992. This law sets forth the rules and methodology for criminal investigations, trials, rendering judgments, conditions for appealing judgments at upper courts, and enforcement of judgments.

Key aspects of the law include:

  • Criminal Investigation: Before a case reaches court, an investigation is carried out by public prosecutors to gather evidence against the accused and to determine whether a case has merit. If sufficient evidence is found, the public prosecutor will initiate a criminal case.

  • Trial: During the trial, the public prosecutor represents the public and presents the case against the accused. The accused is allowed to have legal representation to defend themselves in court. Both parties can present witnesses and evidence to support their respective case.

  • Judgment: After hearing the arguments and examining the evidence, the judge will render a judgment based on the merit of the case and the applicable law.

  • Appeals: If either party is dissatisfied with the judgment, they can appeal the decision to a higher court. The appellate court will review the case and either confirm, amend, or reverse the original judgment.

Police and Investigations

In the United Arab Emirates, the police play a crucial role in the legal process of criminal cases. They are responsible for safeguarding the public, taking initial statements from complainants and witnesses, arresting suspects, carrying out investigations, and executing orders from the Public Prosecution to assist in the investigation process1.

As a part of law enforcement, the police work closely with other authorities such as the Dubai Public Prosecution to ensure the correct procedures are followed and justice is served.

Public Prosecution

The Public Prosecution in the UAE has the authority to initiate and conduct investigations into criminal activities. Once a complaint is filed with the local police in the jurisdiction where the offence was committed, the matter is referred to the public prosecutor2. The prosecutor will then summon the complainant and the accused separately for an interview, with both parties having the opportunity to bring witnesses to testify in their favor before the prosecutor3.

The Public Prosecution plays a vital role in the legal process, as they decide whether or not to proceed with the case based on the evidence gathered during the investigation. If the prosecutor decides to proceed, the case moves forward to the court system.

Court System

The UAE follows a court system that includes a set of rules that designate the procedure and measures for criminal investigation, the trial of the defendant, interpreting judgment, circumstances for appealing judgment at higher courts, and the execution of that judgment4.

The Federal Law No. 35 of 1992, as amended, specifies the procedures for criminal cases, which involve the Court of First Instance, the Court of Appeal, and the Court of Cassation5. Each level of the court system has its jurisdiction and authority. The defendant has the right to appeal judgments at higher courts based on specific conditions and within a specified timeframe.

In conclusion, the legal process of criminal cases in the UAE involves various authorities and steps, including the police, Public Prosecution, and the court system. Each entity plays an essential role in ensuring that justice is effectively served according to the law.

Rights and Roles of Those Involved

Victims and Complainants

In the UAE, the rights of victims and complainants are protected during criminal proceedings. The initial role of the police is to safeguard the public, take statements from complainants, and witnesses, arrest suspects, and carry out investigations 1. It is crucial for victims and complainants to cooperate with the police and provide accurate information to ensure a fair and effective investigation.

Defendants and Accused

The defendants, or the accused, in UAE criminal cases also have specific rights and roles. They are summoned to appear before the competent criminal court and are provided with the details of the crime they have been charged with 2. The accused is entitled to a fair trial, including the right to legal representation and the opportunity to present their defense.

Legal representatives and lawyers play a crucial role in protecting the rights of victims, complainants, and the accused throughout the criminal proceedings in the UAE. They can assist with providing legal advice, understanding the charges, preparing a defense strategy, and representing their clients in court 3. It is important for individuals involved in a criminal case to seek the assistance of a knowledgeable and experienced lawyer to ensure their rights are upheld during the legal process.

Punishments and Penalties

Imprisonment

In the United Arab Emirates, crimes are categorized into three groups where each crime has corresponding punishments in relation to its seriousness. Contraventions, or minor offenses, carry the least severe punishment ranging from 24 hours to 10 days of detention, whereas misdemeanours can result in imprisonment for one month to three years1. Felonies, being the most severe criminal offenses, can lead to life imprisonment or even the death sentence2.

Fines

Fines are another method of punishment in the UAE. The amount of the fine typically depends on the severity of the crime committed. For example, the fine levied for a contravention generally does not exceed 1000 Dirhams3. The UAE Judicial System may impose fines in addition to imprisonment, or as an alternative punishment depending on the nature of the offense.

Travel Bans

The UAE authorities may enforce a travel ban on an individual charged with or convicted of a criminal offense. This ban restricts the person from leaving the country, usually until the resolution of the legal proceedings or the completion of the imposed punishment. A travel ban may also be applied for individuals owing a debt or involved in a civil dispute4.

Confiscation of Assets

In certain cases, the UAE courts can order the confiscation of assets related to criminal activities. This measure is taken to prevent criminals from benefiting from the proceeds of their illegal actions5. Confiscation orders may include assets such as property, vehicles, and bank accounts. This measure is particularly common in cases involving financial crimes, money laundering, and drug trafficking.

Footnotes

  1. Felonies in the UAE ↩

  2. An Overview of Criminal Proceedings in Dubai ↩

  3. Punishments On Criminal Offenses in the UAE ↩

  4. Criminal cases ↩

  5. Punishments On Criminal Offenses in the UAE – Chambers and Partners ↩

Specific Offenses and Regulations

Money Laundering

Money laundering is a serious criminal offense in the UAE. It typically involves the transfer or concealment of illicit funds, making them appear as if they were obtained legally. The UAE has implemented stringent anti-money laundering laws to combat this crime. These laws are designed to target not only the individuals directly involved in money laundering activities, but also financial institutions and professionals that may be aiding or facilitating these transactions.

Theft and Fraud

Theft and fraud are both considered criminal offenses in the UAE. Theft is the act of taking another person’s property without their consent, while fraud typically involves deception and misrepresentation to gain an advantage or financial benefit. These crimes can range from simple pickpocketing to more sophisticated forms of electronic fraud. The UAE penal code stipulates severe penalties for these offenses, including fines and imprisonment. Furthermore, the country has embraced advanced technology to combat and prevent electronic fraud, by continuously updating its regulations and systems to stay ahead of cybercriminals.

Insult and Slander

Insult and slander are offenses that fall under the category of felonies in the UAE. They involve making false or defamatory statements that harm the reputation of another person or entity. Insults can be verbal or written, while slander typically involves spreading false information through various communication methods such as social media, newspapers, or broadcasts.

In the UAE, there are specific laws governing these offenses to protect the society’s moral and social fabric. Accused individuals can face serious consequences, including fines, imprisonment, or deportation for non-UAE nationals. It is important to note that the UAE’s legal system places a strong emphasis on respecting personal rights and dignity. As such, any statement or action deemed offensive or defamatory can potentially result in legal trouble.

Appeal Process and Amnesty

Court of Appeal

In the UAE, convicted individuals have the right to appeal their case in the Court of Appeal. The Federal Law No. 35 of 1992, as amended, outlines the procedures for criminal cases in the country. It encompasses rules and procedures for criminal investigation, the trial of the accused, rendering judgement, and conditions for appealing the judgement at upper courts.

The Dubai Criminal Court, one of the prominent courts handling criminal cases in the UAE, strictly follows the laws and processes prescribed for the appeal process. Submission of a case for review in the Court of Appeal requires adherence to specific criteria and timeframes, ensuring that the appeal follows due process.

Amnesty Policies

Amnesty International has expressed concerns regarding the criminal justice system in the UAE, primarily about the disregard for due process and use of secret detention centers. However, the UAE government has initiated a series of amnesty policies to tackle some human rights issues. These amnesties often involve pardons and releases of prisoners, as well as an opportunity for individuals living in the country without valid residency permits to rectify their legal status without facing penalties.

While these amnesty policies represent a positive step towards addressing some human rights concerns, it is essential to maintain vigilance over their implementation. Issues such as arbitrary detentions of dissidents who completed their sentences or denial of appropriate medical care for detained human rights activists should be addressed more comprehensively. The UAE government should continue to work on enhancing transparency, commitment to due process, and fair treatment within its criminal justice system.

Language and Jurisdiction in Criminal Cases

In the United Arab Emirates (UAE), the official language used in criminal court proceedings is Arabic. All court documents, filings, and correspondences must be in Arabic or accompanied by a certified Arabic translation. Non-Arabic speakers involved in criminal cases typically require the assistance of legal professionals and interpreters to navigate the process effectively.

Jurisdiction in criminal cases is generally determined based on the location where the alleged crime took place. Each of the seven emirates in the UAE has its own local judicial system, which operates under the federal judiciary of the UAE. This means that the emirate in which the crime occurred is typically the competent authority to handle the criminal case.

The court structure in the UAE comprises three levels: the Court of First Instance, the Court of Appeal, and the Federal Supreme Court. In the context of criminal cases, the Court of First Instance usually serves as the competent court to hear the case. If a party is not satisfied with the judgment, they have the option to appeal the decision to a higher court.

In summary, the UAE’s criminal justice system operates in Arabic and follows a jurisdictional framework based on the location of the alleged crime. With a three-tiered court structure, the system allows for appeals and additional scrutiny, ensuring that all parties involved in criminal cases receive a fair and thorough evaluation of their case.

Special Scenarios and Considerations

In the UAE, criminal cases have various special scenarios and considerations that affect how the legal process unfolds. This section covers these unique situations, focusing on three specific sub-sections: women in criminal cases, minors in criminal cases, and crimes involving foreign nationals.

Women in Criminal Cases

When dealing with criminal cases involving women, the UAE legal system takes into consideration the cultural sensitivities and gender-specific circumstances. The enforcement and judiciary authorities strive to provide the necessary support and resources for women victims of crime. There is a concerted effort by the government to ensure the fair trial and treatment of both female defendants and complainants.

Minors in Criminal Cases

The UAE legal system follows a more lenient approach towards minors (less than 18 years) involved in criminal cases. The public prosecution is often understanding of the age, education, and other factors surrounding juvenile offenders. The objective is to rehabilitate and reintegrate them into society while motivating them to complete their education and develop their future potential.

Crimes Involving Foreign Nationals

As home to a diverse population, the UAE experiences criminal cases involving foreign nationals. Dubai and Abu Dhabi follow proper legal procedures to ensure the rights of foreign individuals are protected. In such cases, the authorities communicate with the respective embassies and provide legal assistance as required.

Overall, the UAE’s criminal legal system strives to maintain attentive to the unique scenarios and considerations that affect its diverse population. Through a focus on justice, fairness, and rehabilitation, UAE law aims to accommodate a variety of circumstances in the pursuit of a safe and harmonious society.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the common punishments for criminal offenses in UAE?

In the UAE, criminal offenses may result in a range of punishments depending on the severity of the crime. Contraventions, which are considered minor offenses, may result in a fine not exceeding 1000 Dirhams and custody for at least 24 hours up to 10 days source. For more serious offenses, punishments can include imprisonment, fines, or deportation for expatriates.

How can one check their criminal case status in Dubai?

Individuals can inquire about the status of their criminal case in Dubai through the UAE government’s eServices portal. This service allows users to view information about their case, including the judge’s schedule and court fees.

What are the key differences between criminal and civil cases in UAE?

Criminal cases in the UAE involve offenses against the state or society, whereas civil cases involve disputes between individuals or entities. Criminal cases often result in penalties such as fines, imprisonment, or deportation, while civil cases typically result in compensation or resolution of the dispute through legal means.

How can I resolve a criminal case in UAE?

Resolving a criminal case in the UAE generally involves filing a complaint with the local police station, which will then investigate the incident and, if warranted, refer the case to public prosecution. The prosecutor will review the evidence and decide whether to pursue formal charges. If charges are filed, the case will go to trial, and a judge will consider the evidence and determine the appropriate outcome source.

What constitutes a misdemeanor in UAE?

Misdemeanors in the UAE are considered less severe offenses than felonies. They can include crimes such as issuing a bounced check, public intoxication, or minor traffic violations. Punishments for misdemeanors vary depending on the nature of the crime and may include fines, imprisonment, or community service source.

What are the essential aspects of criminal law in UAE?

Some essential aspects of UAE criminal law include the classification of crimes, the distinction between criminal and civil cases, and the procedures for filing and resolving criminal complaints. Additionally, the UAE legal system follows the principles of Sharia law and incorporates elements from other legal traditions. This combination contributes to the unique characteristics of criminal law in the UAE.